Part IThe Story
The test needed no equipment. A woman picked up a wrapped loaf of bread between her thumb and second finger and squeezed. If the loaf collapsed, so that thumb and finger met almost at once, the bread was judged fresh. In 1948 Americans bought forty million loaves a day, about eighty percent of them white and most of those made from bleached flour, and nearly all of them passed this test. They were made of what bakers call sponge dough, raised four times, and many were sliced, which made them more convenient and helped them go stale faster.
One loaf failed. A housewife who squeezed a large, unsliced Pepperidge Farm loaf for the first time was, in the dry words of The New Yorker, "surprised, if not disgusted." Her fingers did not meet. The loaf pushed back. "It resists," the magazine reported, "like bread."
The woman who made it was fifty years old and had red hair and green eyes. She walked through a two-story U-shaped concrete bakery on the Boston Post Road in Norwalk, Connecticut, in a white smock. When she passed the slicing machine, which she had installed a couple of years earlier "in a moment of weakness," she sometimes said, half to herself and half to whoever was with her: "May the good Lord forgive me."
Margaret Rudkin did not eat sliced bread and had never advertised the bread she made. She charged thirty-one cents for a twenty-two-ounce loaf when the cheap loaves cost far less. She employed twice as many people as the leading factory to produce less than half as much. For eleven years she had followed almost none of the accepted rules of American manufacturing, and she had grown at a rate later calculated at 53 percent a year, every year, for a quarter century.
Everything else in the story grows out of that resistance between thumb and finger: a product that refused to give, sold to a country that had mostly stopped asking for one. So does a smaller paradox inside it. The bread that tasted of an imagined Yankee farmhouse was made by an Irish-American bank clerk from Manhattan who had never farmed before she moved to Connecticut, and who learned to bake from a grandmother in a brownstone that now lies under a forty-story apartment complex near the United Nations.
By the Numbers
The Loaf That Resisted
25¢Price of the first loaf in 1937, against roughly 10¢ for factory bread
8Loaves in the wicker basket she carried to Mercurio's Market in Fairfield
4,000Loaves sold per week within a year of that first delivery
53%Average annual growth rate across her 25 years running the company
$24 → $8MPayroll, from $24 a week to $8 million a year
1 → 50Product categories under her management
$28MValue of the Campbell Soup stock she received for the company in 1961
A brownstone under Tudor City
Her biography begins with a house that no longer exists.
Margaret Loreta Fogarty was born in Manhattan on September 14, 1897, the eldest of five children of Joseph Fogarty and Margaret Healy. The sources disagree about her father. One calls him an Irish clerk; another says he drove a truck. Either way, he was not rich. Until she was twelve, the family lived in her grandmother's four-story brownstone on the East Side, on land later cleared for Tudor City. Tudor City is a 1920s development of mock-English towers whose name, by coincidence or something better, matched the half-timbered house she would later build in Connecticut.
Her mother's mother was the important person in that house. She taught the girl cakes and biscuits first, and she ran her kitchen on observation rather than instruments. Decades later, in the memoir chapters of her cookbook, Rudkin described how that kitchen worked. The roasting was done in the hot oven of a coal stove. All the drafts were opened, and the oven was tested with a piece of white paper: "the exact minutes necessary to brown the paper were carefully computed. Who needed an oven thermometer?"
The household was frugal. The Christmas goose was stuffed with mashed potatoes, onions simmered in butter, dried bread crumbs, two beaten eggs, sage, thyme, and chopped giblets. The goose fat was skimmed off several times during roasting. It could not be allowed to burn, because it was saved, mixed with camphorated oil, and rubbed on the children's chests when they had colds. In that kitchen the same food fed you and treated you. Rudkin's 1948 profile said the Fogartys "believed there was some connection between good food and good health." That idea would eventually earn her $28 million.
The other memory she kept was about want and its satisfaction. At Thanksgiving, she wrote, she cared less about the turkey than the stuffing. She loved it so much that after the bird was "stuffed to bursting," an extra portion was tied in cheesecloth and set in the pan beside it, where the fat sizzled around it. When the cloth was opened there was "a crisp golden ball with a soft, spicy, fragrant center, all for me."
All for me. It is the only selfish phrase in the documentary record of a woman who once counted the hours her husband and sons spent on golf in a typical week (twenty-two), presented them with the total, and then said, smiling, "As anybody can see, I'm the meanest wife and mother in the world."
Her grandmother died when Margaret was twelve, and the family moved to Flushing, Queens. The girl who had learned to read an oven by the color of paper went to the public high school there and graduated as valedictorian, most sources say in 1915. She did not go to college. She went to work, which tells you about the family's money and about her.
The upstart redhead in the ledger room
Rudkin told the story of her first job herself, years later, with a precision that shows how much it mattered to her:
"The bank had only ten employees, and until I came along, it had never hired a woman. There were just three of us in the bookkeeping department—two elderly gentlemen, who wore alpaca jackets and sleeve garters, and this upstart redhead. The books were too heavy for me to carry, so the old gentlemen hauled them out of the vault and put them on a high bench every morning, and I sat there all day on a stool making entries."
The bank had no adding machine. At the end of each day the debits and credits were totaled by hand, and if they did not balance, she stayed until she found the error. On several of those late nights her mother came down to the bank with her knitting and sat with her. It is a small scene with a lot in it: an eighteen-year-old girl on a high stool adding a column she cannot lift, and her mother knitting nearby. That is two generations of women's work in one room, one of them paid.
After two years as a bookkeeper she was made a teller, which she liked because "it gave me a chance to talk with people." She stayed at the bank four years in all. "It taught me accuracy and responsibility and gave me a good background for business," she said. Then she added a line that sounds harsh now and probably sounded ordinary then: "Of course, figures have always been easy for me. Right this minute, I can go out to Cliff—he's the comptroller—and say 'What's the cash balance?' and I can tell offhand if it's correct. The average woman, of course, can't even balance her checkbook."
She did not think of herself as the average woman. She also did not think the category was fixed. Later she would say no job a man could do was beyond a woman, and she would staff her bakery almost entirely with women. Both views were sincere. She contradicted herself often and did not seem bothered by it.
In 1919 she became what she called a "customer's woman" at McClure, Jones & Co., a Wall Street brokerage that has since been dissolved. Her job was to explain investments to clients. One of the partners was Henry Albert Rudkin, a tall, well-dressed native New Yorker twelve years older than she was. A later biographer noted that he "had the advantage of being an Irish New Yorker" as well. He played polo well enough to keep a string of ten ponies, and for years he was president of the Fairfield County Hunt Club Polo Association. They married on April 8, 1923. She was twenty-five. The clerk's daughter had married a partner.
There were three sons: Henry Jr. in 1924, William in 1926, and Mark in 1929. The youngest was born the year the market crashed and the year the family moved to the country.
Ten ponies and a pepperidge tree
The record is unclear on exactly when the land was bought. Accounts give 1926 or 1928, and the size as 123 acres, 125 acres, and in one enthusiastic retelling 320. The New Yorker, writing while the family still lived there, says Henry bought the tract near Fairfield in 1928, built a house, and moved the family in the next year. What is consistent is the house: a large Tudor mansion with a garage for five cars and stables for twelve horses, set among lawns and English gardens. On the front lawn stood an old pepperidge tree, the black tupelo, also called black gum or sour gum, whose leaves turn scarlet in autumn. The Rudkins named the estate after it.
"One of our whimsical ideas," Rudkin wrote, "was to live a real country life."
The word to notice is whimsical. Pepperidge Farm the brand would sell the authenticity of country life for decades. Pepperidge Farm the place started as a stockbroker's idea of it, a 1920s Wall Street couple's version of a squire's estate. The boys had a governess who taught them good French. They sailed at the Pequot Yacht Club in Southport. Margaret showed horses and won ribbons. Henry played polo. It was a performance of country life, and that is not a criticism. Most American class mobility involves some performance before it becomes real.
Then two things happened. The market collapsed, and Henry was hurt on a horse. Sources date the polo accident to 1932, though The New Yorker describes him breaking his hip in a fall "several years" before 1948, so there may have been more than one fall. He could not work for six months. Wall Street, as one 1939 account put it, "was in the doldrums."
Margaret took over the household's finances the way she had once balanced the ledger. She sold the horses and all the cars but one. She let the full-time servants go. She sold apples from the estate's orchard, which one account puts at five hundred trees, and turkeys raised on the property. One writer says she learned to butcher hogs, and I have found no reason to doubt it. The woman who had been a society matron with a governess and twelve stalls became, in practice, a smallholder working to keep the property.
The farm stopped being a whim. She was in her mid-thirties, she had three young sons, and her husband was injured. The country life was now real whether they wanted it or not.
Stone Age bread
The official origin story goes like this. In 1937 the Rudkins' youngest son, Mark, then about nine, developed asthma. The family doctor or an allergist blamed additives in processed food and prescribed a diet of fruit, vegetables, and minimally processed food. Rudkin decided to bake him bread like her grandmother's: stone-ground whole wheat, whole milk, butter, honey, and molasses, with nothing removed and nothing synthetic added.
"Natural foods and natural sugars and the wheat germ contained in old-fashioned whole wheat bread," she said, "might help this child who needed special food."
Some details complicate this. The New Yorker reported in 1948 that "a couple of doctors prescribed taking him to Arizona," the standard cure for asthmatic children of the time, but she chose to keep him at home and treat him with diet. The same article noted, with evident pleasure, that the youngest son was "getting a trifle tired of the story that his asthma … caused his mother to go into the baking business." And in the company's official history, written in her own hand, she did not mention Mark's illness at all. She said only that she had been interested in "proper food for children."
I do not think she was hiding anything. She was keeping the boy out of the marketing, which is unusual among founders. The story of the sick child was useful, and she declined to use it herself. Others told it for her.
The first loaf was a failure, and she said so plainly:
"My first loaf of bread should have been sent to the Smithsonian Institution as a sample of Stone Age bread, for it was hard as a rock and about one inch high. So I started over again, and after a few more efforts by trial and error, we achieved what seemed like good bread."
She had ground the flour herself in a kitchen coffee mill, using wheat bought at a local feed store, so the texture was rough. She had never baked bread. She knew cakes and biscuits from her grandmother, and she had a collection of old cookbooks she liked to read. Some accounts say she had not even understood yeast at first. She was forty. "They say life begins at forty," she later said. "Well, that's how old I was when I baked that first loaf."
The bread seemed to help her son. She told one of his doctors. The doctor asked whether she would bake a few loaves for his other patients, and then he wrote a letter endorsing it. Rudkin took the letter to other doctors, and they began recommending the bread too. A Fairfield housewife's whole-wheat loaf was now effectively prescribed by physicians. It was a clever bit of positioning, and she managed it before she had sold a single loaf.
Friends who tasted it told her it was good enough to sell even to people who were not sick. The Reader's Digest account from 1939 records how she reasoned about it, in a passage more modest and more interesting than the usual founder story: "Hundreds of people in nearby Bridgeport needed work. Wall Street, which supplied the family income, was in the doldrums. Perhaps this talk of enthusiastic friends made sense. Perhaps there were a lot of families tired of the tasteless sponge fed to them by the baking industry."
She was not trying to change how Americans ate. She was asking whether there were enough tired families to make it pay.
Eight loaves in a wicker basket
Her equipment says a lot about how she started.
She fenced off a corner of the garage, which with only one car left was mostly empty. She brought an old stove up from the basement. From the attic she took a pair of baby scales, which had weighed her three sons, and used them to weigh dough. She bought a few dollars' worth of mixing bowls and baking tins and a bread mixer about the size of a water pail from Sears, Roebuck. She hired a neighbor's daughter to help.
Then came the decision that would shape the company for twenty-five years. In the Digest's words: "At the outset, she decided on no compromise with quality. Instead of trying to work within a price, Mrs. Rudkin made the best loaf she could conceive, then computed a price. It worked out to 25 cents."
Factory bread cost about a dime. She had built in a premium of two and a half times, and the commercial bakers she talked to told her people would never pay it.
One morning in 1937 (The New Yorker says fall, most other accounts say August), she put eight loaves of whole-wheat bread in a wicker basket and took them to Mercurio's Market in Fairfield. The owner, Jimmy Mercurio, was a friend. One version says he was skeptical and she convinced him by letting him taste a slice. Either way, he agreed to try selling them at twenty-five cents.
About two hours later he called. The bread was gone, and he wanted a regular, larger order.
This is the most familiar scene in her story, and it is worth looking at closely. Eight loaves sold out in about two hours in a Depression-era Connecticut town, at more than twice the going price, with no advertising, no label anyone knew, and no explanation beyond a handwritten recommendation from a doctor. A market had been waiting for someone to show up.
The second market came through Henry. As he recovered and went back to commuting to Wall Street, he carried loaves into Manhattan. Soon Charles & Company, the expensive specialty grocer, had a standing order for twenty-four loaves a day, and for the first few weeks a partner at a brokerage firm delivered them himself on the commuter train. He would later become the company's chairman and handle its finances and marketing. In 1948 The New Yorker found him spending two days a week on brokerage and the rest on bread. In 1949 he left Wall Street for good. He had started the business as its delivery man.
Then the press found her. The New York Journal and American ran a story with a headline that captured everything odd about the venture: "Society Woman Turns Baker To Supply Elite With Healthful Bread." Society, elite, and health were each a selling point, and together they made a story. The Herald Tribune and the World-Telegram followed. In December 1939 Reader's Digest published J. D. Ratcliff's piece, which began with something close to a business thesis: "There is money to be wrung even from commonplace ideas—if mixed with imagination and industry."
Ratcliff's next sentence named the social risk she was taking: "Traditionally, homemade bread has been baked by destitute widows and peddled from door to door on a semi-charitable basis." A Wall Street wife in a Tudor house was doing what poor widows did, and charging more for it. The Digest reached readers across the United States and Canada, and orders came in from both and from overseas. The business that had started at eight loaves a day was selling 25,000 loaves a week, with gross income of about a quarter of a million dollars a year.
That article was not luck. It was suggested by Benjamin Sonnenberg, the New York publicist, and Rudkin paid him not in cash but with a five percent interest in the company. By 1960 that stake was worth more than a million dollars. In 1939 she understood that the right person telling her story was worth part of the company itself, and she paid accordingly.
The minority who are willing to pay
To see what she was up against, consider the industry's view of her.
In 1948 the American baking industry was a large and highly efficient operation built on research. Forty years earlier, ninety-five percent of the nation's bread had been baked at home. By 1948 only five percent was. The industry knew in great detail who ate bread: the average American ate fifty-four and nine-tenths pounds of white bread a year; Rhode Islanders and Washingtonians ate twice that; teenagers ate the most; richer people ate less; consumption bottomed out in January and peaked around Labor Day. And it knew that most Americans, in every season and region, wanted bread that was "bland in taste, soft in texture, and dead white in color."
The New Yorker used a pseudonym, Manna, for one of the most popular loaves, and toured its factory. Manna's bakery employed sixty-five people, all men, to produce ninety-five thousand loaves a day in a five-story brick building the writer compared to "a sanitary warehouse." The dough was mixed twice, raised four times, rolled flat between steel rollers like a clothes wringer, divided by a machine that stamped out eight uniform pieces every three seconds, and baked for thirty minutes at 425 degrees. Vitamins arrived in bars "like laundry soap" and were dissolved into the mix to replace what milling had taken out. The slogan was "Bursting with Air!" The magazine called it accurate.
An official at one of the big firms explained the logic to a writer with a candor that is hard to forget:
— An official of one of the big bread firms, quoted in The New Yorker, May 22, 1948We can make that kind of bread. Anybody can. The only reason we don't is that if we did we'd be out of business in thirty days. The American housewife thinks of bread as a pusher. What she wants is something in the nature of an edible piece of paper she can use to push peanut butter and jam into her kids three times a day, seven days a week. We're not out to change the public taste. We just want to sell bread, and the more of the damned stuff we can sell, the happier we'll be.
An edible piece of paper. He was not wrong, and that is the point. The industry had read the market correctly, and the majority wanted exactly what he described. The white flour that made the paper was bleached with nitrogen trichloride, sold as Agene, which made it keep well, bake predictably, and come out "as snowy white as Kleenex." In the mid-1940s, Sir Edward Mellanby of Britain's Medical Research Council found that dogs fed bread made from heavily agenized flour developed what researchers called "canine hysteria." The U.S. Army's Medical Nutrition Laboratory and a team at the University of Wisconsin found similar effects in cats, rats, and monkeys. The Food and Drug Administration said it had found no evidence of harm to humans. The New Yorker noted that Pepperidge Farm white bread, made from unbleached flour, "will not drive dogs crazy."
Rudkin watched the agene controversy calmly. She had never had to argue her case on safety. Her position was simpler and, commercially, much stronger:
— Margaret Rudkin, to The New Yorker, 1948I am only trying to please the minority who want a good loaf of bread and are willing to pay for it.
She did not try to change the public's taste. The bread lobby's main rule, as stated by the president of the American Bakers Association, was "to make every effort to serve the public what it wants." She agreed with it. She simply defined "the public" as a smaller group. A Wall Street wife who had once been a clerk's daughter understood class from both sides, and she saw that the people who would pay thirty-one cents for a loaf were a market in their own right, and that this market would grow as the country got richer.
It did grow, and she was "not noticeably offended by the increase in the size of the minority," as the magazine put it. The minority she served kept expanding until it was a national market.
Dead pigeons and ingrates
Some of her customers were close to addicted, and the letters show it.
The columnist Dorothy Thompson began eating the bread in 1938 and soon wrote to Rudkin: "I shall eat no other bread." The New Yorker reported a decade later that she had kept her word. A schoolteacher who moved from New Jersey to Iowa wrote: "To be frank, life is not worth living without it. Could you send me even one small loaf?" A retired New York lawyer in California wrote: "Until I get your bread again, dear lady, I shall be a dead pigeon."
So she set up a mail-order service, and by 1948 she was shipping by parcel post to five hundred customers in forty states. Bundles went by air to Americans in Stockholm and Lisbon. Now and then she quick-froze a couple of dozen loaves and sent them in a passenger ship's refrigerator to a Standard Oil executive in Paris, who cabled back: "Bread arrived O.K. Bless you."
The religious language recurs. Several correspondents told her they could not hear the Lord's Prayer, give us this day our daily bread, without thinking of a slice of Pepperidge, plain or toasted. Others compared her bread with their mothers', and the magazine noted that "these letters reveal a great deal of filial ingratitude." One writer from Boston: "I had always thought my mother baked wonderful bread, but yours is better." Rudkin was pleased, the magazine reported, "even though she is aware that her pleasure rests upon the maligning of somebody's mother."
This joke points to something serious. Her customers had been raised by mothers who no longer baked, in a country where home baking had fallen from ninety-five percent to five in one lifetime. They wrote to Rudkin as people write to someone who has given back something they lost. What she sold was the bread of a grandmother's kitchen, the coal stove and the paper browning in the oven, offered to a generation whose mothers had moved on to the edible piece of paper.
She was also an Irish-American woman from a Manhattan brownstone, selling that past back to the country under the name of a Connecticut farm.
Forty women at a sloping table
She moved the business three times in eleven years. When it outgrew the kitchen, she turned the estate's stables into a bakery. That brought the horses back into the story in an odd way: the polo ponies' stalls became proofing rooms. In 1940 she borrowed $15,000 and moved into two adjoining buildings in Norwalk, a former Packard salesroom and a former hospital, joined by an enclosed passage. A car showroom and a hospital: the two halves of her pitch, luxury and health, housed under one roof. Within a year she was producing more than 50,000 loaves a week.
The war slowed her down. Rationing restricted the butter, milk, and honey her recipe required, and she would not substitute, so she cut production. A competitor would have used shortening and called it patriotic. She made less bread instead.
After the war she drew a new bakery herself. She bought fourteen acres on the Boston Post Road and hired an architect. She gave him a large sheet of cardboard on which she had pinned several dozen paper rectangles, each one a piece of equipment, arranged in the order a loaf would travel. "This is how I want the inside laid out," she told him. "Now, you figure out the exterior and the staircases. But don't you dare change my plans."
The building opened on July 4, 1947. It was a two-story U-shaped concrete structure that cost $625,000 to build and equip, and it could turn out four thousand loaves an hour. Almost all of one side was storage, stacked with about six thousand hundred-pound sacks of flour. The other side handled the work of making bread.
A loaf was made like this. One of five women in white uniforms rolled a tinned-steel bowl on casters, big enough for eighty loaves, under a row of wall spigots. She ran in fresh whole milk, then an equal amount of water. As the bowl moved along, others added melted creamery butter, yeast, salt, unsulphured molasses, liquid sugar, and honey. The honey was there for flavor and because, being hygroscopic, it kept the bread fresh longer, so even the sweetener did more than one job. A man added flour from an overhead bin. The dough was mixed once, a straight dough rather than a sponge, which made one step more efficient than Manna's. It then rose for two hours.
After that came the kneading room. Four women at a wooden table cut the dough into loaf-sized pieces with small blades and checked each on a scale. A conveyor carried the pieces past forty women seated at a sloping kneading table. Each woman took a piece, kneaded it "thoughtfully," in the magazine's word, for about a minute, and put it back. Rudkin said it took a new kneader three weeks to learn by touch when the yeast bubbles were evenly distributed.
The loaves rose a second time, in a warmer and more humid room, then baked for an hour at 400 degrees, twice as long as Manna's. Two women in white canvas gloves took them out of the tins. In 1948 a loaf of Pepperidge Farm bread was handled by roughly fifty women before it was wrapped by machine.
A Manna executive once commented on the hand-kneading: "There's no pair of hands in the world that can squeeze like that." He was talking about his steel rollers, and he was right. Rudkin's bet was that the inefficiency was what customers were paying for.
Ninety percent of her workers were women. She believed women were better at making bread than men. She also had a rule against hiring women who baked bread at home, in case they brought in their own habits. She wanted touch without opinions about method. Muzak played in the bakery. "When the girls haven't anything else to do, they get up and dance with each other," she told visitors happily. The New Yorker added that most of "the girls" were gray-haired and "usually have something else to do."
She called all 162 employees by their first names, and they all called her Mrs. Rudkin. She paid a bit more than the industry average and provided bonuses, insurance, medical care, an infirmary with a full-time nurse, and a cafeteria run by two longtime employees, Edna and May, where forty cents bought a meat-and-potato lunch with milk, dessert, and Pepperidge bread. After three years an employee received a week's salary and silver earrings or cuff links. After ten, four weeks' wages and a monogrammed silver fruit bowl. Every employee could buy a loaf a day at half price. The magazine called the arrangement "the benevolent pattern popular among small New England firms" and "not dangerously radical." That was a fair description. She was not a revolutionary. She was a former bookkeeper who had worked out that loyal kneaders cost less than turnover, and who also seemed to like the people she employed.
Her flour supply was its own small piece of the past. Unbleached white flour came from the Russell-Miller Milling Company in Minneapolis. The whole wheat was ground in two water-powered gristmills built around 1750, the Rose Mill in Milford and Winchell Smith's mill in Farmington. Both had been bought about twenty-five years earlier, separately and by coincidence, by wealthy hobbyists: a Hearst executive named Earle McHugh, and Winchell Smith, the co-author of the Broadway hit Lightnin'. The wheat was crushed between French buhrstones, which kept the live wheat germ, the source of the vitamin B she valued. Because the germ is alive it spoils quickly, so flour arrived three times a week and she never kept more than three days' supply, about thirty thousand pounds. From 1952 to 1967 a third mill, in Sudbury, Massachusetts, supplied forty-eight tons of whole-wheat flour a month. The company's logo still shows that mill.
So the most modern bakery in the country depended on colonial mills kept running as hobbies by men from newspapers and the theater.
Very little went to waste. About three percent of the bread came back unsold from stores, which was average for the industry. Roughly a third of her herb-seasoned stuffing and Melba toast was made from those returns. The stuffing, still sold today and still recommended by food editors, came partly from yesterday's unsold bread. It also connects back to the cheesecloth ball of stuffing in her grandmother's turkey pan.
Every weekday she got up at six-thirty, walked around the estate, cooked breakfast, and was at the bakery by eight-thirty. She stayed until six. She and Henry shared a large, plain office. His desk, the bigger one, was neat. Hers was covered with letters, trade journals, baking tins, boxes of rolls, samples of flour and honey, and the water-pail-sized mixer she had bought from Sears to start the business in her kitchen.
"I like to keep it in sight," she said, "so I won't get heady."
Not run by the accepted rules
At a dinner party in the spring of 1947, Rudkin sat next to Georges Doriot of the Harvard School of Business Administration. Doriot was the French-born professor who would shortly found American Research and Development, the first modern venture capital firm. The talk turned to bread. She told him the story of the company, which she usually called "my little fairytale." He invited her to address his manufacturing class.
She enjoyed it enormously:
— Margaret Rudkin, on lecturing at Harvard, 1947I had the time of my life. There were two hundred and forty people in the audience, and they laughed at all my jokes. I told them the story of the business and how it had succeeded because it had never been run according to any of the accepted rules of manufacturing.
She was invited back twice more. One biographer says she was the only woman ever to speak at Harvard Business School three times. That is hard to verify and easy to believe. The picture is odd and a little funny: the bookkeeper who once could not lift the ledgers, telling two hundred and forty future managers that the rules they were learning had not applied to her, and getting laughs.
There was something performed about her, and she knew it. She called herself "just a housewife" on a morning radio program, then gave a short economics lecture on how government price guarantees for farmers were "sheer economic nonsense," and told the listening housewives to write their congressmen. She did her own cooking after letting the servants go. She could "whip up a cake in fifteen minutes. I've timed myself." She had stopped keeping a full-time cook after a Finnish couple she employed had to be dismissed "because they kept getting into the liquor." In 1948 she was still wearing an evening wrap she had bought in 1926. She thought bridge, golf, and cocktail parties were a waste of time. When the family dined in the city, it was at the Colony or Voisin.
She was a housewife with a factory, a society woman who distrusted society, and a self-made businesswoman whose start had depended on a stockbroker husband, a Tudor estate, and a doctor's letter. She was all of these at once and did not try to reconcile them.
In 1948, for their twenty-fifth anniversary, Henry gave her the summer off. He would run the business while she sailed to Europe on the Queen Elizabeth with their two unmarried sons.
"It will be the first time in my life that I have ever done anything just for fun," she said. "The boys say they won't allow me to visit a single bakery. Now, isn't that dreadful?"
It was the first time she had done anything just for fun since the stuffing in the cheesecloth.
Importing the old world
The boys did not prevail for long. Europe became her source of new products.
In the 1950s she returned from trips with ideas the American market did not yet have. She bought cookie recipes from the Delacre bakery in Belgium, delicate chocolate-filled cookies that fit nothing in American mass-market baking. She bought the rights to produce them in the United States, and the Distinctive Cookies line came out of it. Each cookie was named for a European city: Brussels, and the Milano, which was worked out in Norwalk a few years later. Food marketers later pointed out that Distinctives were cookies home bakers could not easily copy, while the company's Farmhouse line offered chocolate chip and shortbread that anyone could make. She charged the most for what customers could not reproduce at home.
She bought a frozen pastry line from Black Horse Pastry, a New Hampshire firm. Frozen puff pastry reached American freezers under her name and was described in 1958 as "a glamorous new product to America." In Switzerland she liked a small fish-shaped cracker. Pepperidge Farm introduced its own version in 1962, and it became Goldfish, eventually produced at three thousand crackers a second.
In each case she did not invent the product. She found it, bought the rights, and adapted it. The bread had come the same way, from a grandmother's kitchen, a colonial mill, and a Latin-reading idea of what bread used to be. Her talent, as one food writer put it, was "turning obscure good taste into mass-market appeal." She found good things in obscure places and made them widely available.
She also became the face of the company. Starting around 1950, she appeared in television commercials for her own products, a red-haired woman at a time when few women ran companies, appearing on a new medium in American living rooms. One description from the period called her "slim and sophisticated, with gorgeous red hair, green eyes, and a milk-white skin." Even so, sales continued to depend more on word of mouth than on advertising.
Then the company made a choice that its later history depends on. Beginning in the mid-1950s (accounts date it to 1956) and continuing for decades, Pepperidge Farm commercials featured a character named Titus Moody, a laconic old Yankee who drove a horse-drawn bakery wagon along country roads and said, in a flat New England voice, the line Americans still recognize: Pepperidge Farm remembers. The actor Parker Fennelly played him, and later another actor took over. The campaign ran about forty years. A surviving photograph shows Rudkin herself holding the reins of the bakery wagon beside Fennelly.
Look at that photograph closely. A Manhattan-born Irish-American woman, a former bank clerk and Wall Street saleswoman, sits next to a hired actor playing an invented Connecticut farmer, and the farmer is the one presented as the company's memory. The New England Historical Society observed that you could be "forgiven for thinking Pepperidge Farm was founded by someone like Titus Moody." The ads were designed to create exactly that impression.
What Pepperidge Farm "remembered" was never quite its own past. The ads drew on a general nostalgia for early twentieth-century rural life, a period in which young Margaret Fogarty was living in a brownstone on East 42nd Street, learning to judge an oven by browning paper. Her actual memory was urban, immigrant, and female. The brand's memory was rural, Yankee, and male. She allowed the second to stand in for the first, possibly because she understood that Americans pay more for the past they would like to have had than for the one they did.
Twenty-eight million dollars of soup
By 1960 Pepperidge Farm earned $1.3 million on sales of $32 million. It had bakeries in Pennsylvania (opened 1949) and Illinois (1953). Delivery had grown from one operator, Henry on the commuter train, to an independent network of more than five hundred. Product categories had grown from one to fifty. Time profiled her that March as a "Champion of the Old-Fashioned." In 1955 she had received the Medallion of Honor at the Women's International Exposition. Decades later Fortune would name her the most powerful woman in American business for 1950 to 1960.
She had also had breast cancer surgery around 1956. Very little is recorded about it. She was not someone who discussed her health in public.
In 1961 the Rudkins sold Pepperidge Farm to the Campbell Soup Company for Campbell stock worth about $28 million, roughly $28.2 million by one precise count. Measured against the eight-loaf basket, it was an enormous return. Measured against the brand that would later sell more than a billion dollars a year in more than forty countries, it was modest. She probably knew both things.
She did not simply leave. As part of the deal she joined Campbell's board as its first female director. She kept running the business for a while. In 1962 her son William became president of Pepperidge Farm, and she eventually succeeded Henry as chair. The family now held shares in the company that made the red-and-white soup cans Andy Warhol painted that same year.
In 1957, for the company's twentieth anniversary, each of its roughly one thousand employees had contributed one dollar. With the money they bought her a fifteenth-century cookbook, De Honesta Voluptate et Valetudine, "Of Honest Indulgence and Good Health," written by the Vatican librarian Bartolomeo Platina and printed in Venice around 1475. It is often called the first printed cookbook. The title states her whole business in Latin: indulgence and health, presented as compatible. She found a young professor to translate it.
She used it in The Margaret Rudkin Pepperidge Farm Cookbook, published by Atheneum in 1963 and illustrated by the Danish artist Erik Blegvad. Its organization is unusual. It is arranged by periods of her life rather than by courses: Childhood, Country Life, Pepperidge Farm, Ireland. Between these memoir sections sits a fourth, "Cooking from Antique Cookbooks," with Platina's fifteenth-century recipes printed alongside her modern versions. It runs to about 440 pages and more than five hundred recipes. By most accounts it was the first cookbook ever to reach the New York Times best-seller list. A reviewer in the Rocky Mount Telegram wrote: "A remark often heard at the supermarket is, 'anything put out by Pepperidge Farm is bound to be good,' and this cookbook is up to the standard."
The section titled "Ireland" deserves a note. In her last years the Rudkins divided their time between Hobe Sound, Florida, and County Carlow, Ireland. The Fogarty granddaughter had returned, in a sense, to the country her grandmother had left. Her actual history, the Irish one rather than the Yankee one the ads told, finally appears on its own terms in a chapter of a best-selling book.
Henry Rudkin died on April 22, 1966, at eighty. She stepped down as chair a few months later. By then the cancer was advanced. She gave her large collection of cookbooks to the Pequot Library in Southport, the same village where her sons had sailed as boys, and made gifts to Yale-New Haven Hospital, where she died on June 1, 1967. She was sixty-nine. The New York Times obituary headline noted that the "Home-Baked Business Grew to $50-Million Yearly and National Distribution." She was buried in Woodlawn Cemetery in the Bronx, back in the city she came from rather than in Connecticut.
Her youngest son, Mark, the asthmatic boy who grew tired of being the origin story, became a landscape architect in France and designed gardens, among them the Jardins du Nouveau Monde at the Château de Blérancourt, a museum of Franco-American history. In 2023 Campbell's announced it would close Pepperidge Farm's headquarters in Norwalk and move the jobs to Camden, New Jersey. The pepperidge tree, the mills, the house, and the stables that served as a bakery are gone or bypassed, reduced to a logo and a name.
What she left in the cookbook is a coal stove with every draft open, and a grandmother sliding a sheet of plain white paper into the oven and watching it closely, counting the minutes until it browned.
Part IIThe Playbook
Rudkin did not leave a management philosophy. She left a set of decisions, many of them contrary to the conventional wisdom of the industry she entered. The principles below are drawn from those decisions, from the pricing of the first loaf to the structure of the Campbell sale. They are not the obvious lessons. "Make a quality product" applies to everyone and teaches little. The more useful material is in how she defined her customer, which inefficiencies she chose to keep, and whose credibility she borrowed when she had none.
The principles
- 1.Build the product first, then compute the price.
- 2.Serve the minority and let it grow.
- 3.Protect the inefficiency customers are paying for.
- 4.Borrow authority before you sell.
- 5.Pay the storyteller in equity.
- 6.Design the inside; delegate the outside.
- 7.Hire for touch, not habit.
- 8.Turn your returns into a product line.
- 9.Scout instead of invent.
- 10.Sell the founder's past, not the founder's biography.
- 11.Keep the first tool on the desk.
- 12.Sell at the top, but keep a seat in the room.
Principle 1
Build the product first, then compute the price
Most consumer products are designed backward from a price point: decide what the market will bear, then engineer the product to fit. Rudkin did the opposite, and the 1939 Reader's Digest account states it clearly: "Instead of trying to work within a price, Mrs. Rudkin made the best loaf she could conceive, then computed a price. It worked out to 25 cents." Commercial bakers told her nobody would pay it. Mercurio's sold out in about two hours.
The approach sounds reckless, but it reflects her bookkeeping training. She was not ignoring cost. She was refusing to let a competitor's cost structure set her product's specifications. Whole milk, creamery butter, honey, stone-ground flour, and an hour in the oven determined the price. Her price discipline showed up in other ways, too. She dropped prewar pound cakes once she calculated they would have to sell for three times their old fifty-cent price, and during rationing she cut production rather than substitute shortening for butter.
The premium also told customers what kind of product it was. A twenty-five-cent loaf could not be mistaken for a ten-cent one, and the gap justified itself with every slice.
Tactic: Write the specification for the best version of your product before looking at competitors' pricing, then price it at full cost plus margin and test whether a real market exists at that number.
Principle 2
Serve the minority and let it grow
The baking industry's rule, in its trade association's words, was "to make every effort to serve the public what it wants." Rudkin accepted the rule and changed its scope: "I am only trying to please the minority who want a good loaf of bread and are willing to pay for it." She did not try to convert people who wanted an edible piece of paper. She served those who did not.
The important point is that a minority in a growing economy does not stay small. The 1948 industry data showed that people ate less bread as they became richer, which meant the bread they did eat had to be better. Postwar affluence enlarged her niche every year. She was not opposing the majority. She was waiting for more of them to cross over.
Her mail-order business shows how tightly she held the minority. Five hundred customers in forty states, loaves frozen and shipped by ship to Paris, cables saying "Bless you." Customers that devoted act as a sales force, and she supplied them deliberately, even when it was expensive.
Tactic: Identify the small group of customers who will write you letters if you disappear, serve them at whatever cost it takes to keep them, and check whether broader economic trends are pushing more people into that group.
Principle 3
Protect the inefficiency customers are paying for
Rudkin employed twice as many people as the Manna factory to produce less than half as much bread. By any standard productivity measure her bakery was inefficient. It also grew 53 percent a year.
The reason is that the inefficiencies were the product. Two risings instead of four made a denser loaf. An hour in the oven instead of thirty minutes developed the crust. Forty women kneading at a sloping table produced the texture that "resists, like bread." She was not attached to old methods for their own sake. She used a straight dough because it was more efficient than a sponge, ran conveyors and wrapping machines, and kept the bakery running twenty-four hours a day. She automated what customers would not notice and kept by hand what they would.
M
Manna vs. Pepperidge Farm, 1948
The New Yorker's comparison of a leading mass-market loaf (pseudonymous 'Manna') with Rudkin's bakery.
| Variable | Manna | Pepperidge Farm | Choice |
|---|---|---|---|
| Workforce | 65 employees, all men | ~130–162 employees, 90% women | Kept costly |
| Daily output | 95,000 loaves | ~40,000 loaves | Kept costly |
| Mixing | Sponge dough, two mixings | Straight dough, one mixing | Automated / streamlined |
| Kneading | Steel rollers | Forty women by hand | Kept costly |
| Risings | Four | Two | Product-defining |
| Baking | 30 min at 425°F | 60 min at 400°F | Product-defining |
| Flour | Bleached (Agene) | Unbleached; stone-ground whole wheat | Supply-chain risk |
| Wrapping | Machine | Machine | Automated / streamlined |
Tactic: List every step in your process, mark which ones a customer can actually taste, feel, or notice, keep those manual or premium no matter what efficiency consultants say, and automate everything else.
In 1937 Rudkin had no reputation as a baker, no brand, and no credentials. Before approaching a single grocer, she got a doctor to write a letter endorsing her bread, took the letter to other doctors, and had them recommend it to their patients. Her first customers were effectively given the bread on a doctor's advice.
She did not overstate that endorsement. In her own official history she wrote only that she cared about "proper food for children," and she left the sick-son story to others. But she understood that for a new product, the credibility of an outside expert counted for far more than a founder's claims. The Journal and American headline put it in one line: Society Woman (status), Turns Baker (novelty), Healthful Bread (medical authority). Each word added credibility she could not have supplied herself.
Tactic: Before your first sale, find the professional your customer already trusts on the problem you solve, earn a written endorsement from them, and make that endorsement the core of your first pitch.
Principle 5
Pay the storyteller in equity
The December 1939 Reader's Digest article took Pepperidge Farm from a regional novelty to a business with orders from across North America and overseas. It was suggested by the publicist Benjamin Sonnenberg, and Rudkin paid him with five percent of the company. By 1960 his stake was worth more than a million dollars.
Most founders in 1939 would have paid a fee, if they paid anything. Rudkin saw that the right story in the right outlet at the right time was not a cost but a lasting asset, something like an investment in the company. Paying him in equity gave Sonnenberg a reason to keep promoting her, and it cost her no cash at a time when she was borrowing $15,000 to move out of the stables.
It also explains how a company that "has never been advertised," as The New Yorker noted in 1948, became nationally known. It had excellent press placement, paid for in ownership.
Tactic: When someone can give your company a story that reaches far beyond your current customers, consider paying them with a small equity stake rather than a fee, so their incentives stay tied to yours for years.
Principle 6
Design the inside; delegate the outside
When Rudkin hired an architect for the 1947 Norwalk bakery, she gave him a piece of cardboard with paper rectangles pinned in the order of production: "This is how I want the inside laid out. Now, you figure out the exterior and the staircases. But don't you dare change my plans."
That division of work is easy to overlook. She claimed control of the workflow, the sequence of mixing, rising, kneading, and baking that produced the product, and gave up control over everything that did not affect it. The building itself was the architect's job. The order of operations was hers. She knew the difference between the two because she had personally done every step, at first in her own kitchen with baby scales.
Founders who control everything tend to slow down, and founders who delegate everything tend to lose what made the product good. Rudkin decided where the line was ahead of time and stated it clearly.
Tactic: Before hiring an expert, draw your own version of the parts of the system that directly shape the customer's experience, give the expert full authority over everything else, and tell them plainly which part is not open for discussion.
Principle 7
Hire for touch, not habit
Ninety percent of Rudkin's workforce was women, many of them older, and she believed women were naturally better at breadmaking. She also refused to hire women who already baked bread at home, "lest they be tempted to introduce a few tricks of their own." Every new kneader spent three weeks developing a feel for when the yeast was evenly distributed.
This sounds contradictory but is consistent. She wanted the ability without the established habits. An experienced home baker would trust her own method. A trainee would learn the company's. Consistency at four thousand loaves an hour depended on that difference.
The benefits supported the same goal: above-average wages, a full-time nurse, the forty-cent cafeteria lunch, silver earrings after three years and a monogrammed fruit bowl after ten. Kneading skill took weeks to build, so it made sense to keep the people who had it. In 1957 a thousand employees each gave her a dollar for a fifteenth-century cookbook, which suggests the arrangement worked well for both sides.
Tactic: When your product depends on skill that takes weeks to teach, hire for aptitude rather than experience, train everyone to one standard, and pay well enough that the trained people stay.
Principle 8
Turn your returns into a product line
About three percent of Pepperidge Farm bread came back from stores unsold, the industry average. Rudkin made roughly a third of her herb-seasoned stuffing and Melba toast from it. Bread that would have been a loss became a second product, and the stuffing lasted so well that food editors still recommend it decades later.
The waste stream was only part of it. The stuffing came from a real conviction, the cheesecloth stuffing from her grandmother's Thanksgiving table, and she made it from material her own process left over. She repeated the pattern elsewhere: stone-ground flour, cracked wheat, cornmeal, and Scotch-style oatmeal sold by mail in five-pound bags; macaroons tested on the side. Each new product came out of capabilities or materials she already had.
Tactic: Look at whatever your operation currently throws away or writes off, and ask what product your best customers would happily buy that could be made from it.
Principle 9
Scout instead of invent
The Distinctive cookies came from recipes bought from the Delacre bakery in Belgium. The frozen pastry came from Black Horse Pastry in New Hampshire. Goldfish came from a cracker she liked in Switzerland. The bread itself came from her grandmother. Rudkin rarely invented anything from scratch. Her skill was spotting things that were excellent, little known, and hard to copy, and then buying the rights and producing them at scale.
The cookie lines show how deliberate this was. The Distinctives, each named for a European city, were cookies a home baker could not easily make. The Farmhouse line was cookies anyone could. The premium went to the products customers could not reproduce, and the European names supported both the price and the impression of sophistication.
P
The Acquisition Pipeline
Where Pepperidge Farm's major product lines actually came from.
1937
Whole-wheat loaf, from her Irish grandmother's recipe and Manhattan kitchen.
1947
Norwalk bakery opens July 4; stuffing and Melba toast made partly from returned bread.
1950s
Cookie recipes bought from Delacre bakery, Belgium; Distinctive line launched, Milano developed in Norwalk.
1950s
Frozen pastry line bought from Black Horse Pastry, New Hampshire; puff pastry called "a glamorous new product to America" by 1958.
1962
Goldfish crackers, adapted from a fish-shaped cracker Rudkin encountered in Switzerland.
1963
De Honesta Voluptate (c. 1475), a gift from employees, translated and adapted for her cookbook.
Tactic: Travel with the explicit goal of finding products that are already good but little known outside their home market, buy the rights while they are cheap, and spend your effort on scaling them rather than inventing.
Principle 10
Sell the founder's past, not the founder's biography
This is the least comfortable lesson, and possibly the most valuable. Rudkin was an Irish-American from Manhattan, a bank clerk who became a stockbroker's wife. The brand was represented for forty years by Titus Moody, an invented old Yankee on a bakery wagon who said "Pepperidge Farm remembers." The New England Historical Society later observed that consumers could be forgiven for assuming someone like Moody had founded the company.
She allowed that substitution, and even took part in it, posing with the actor who played Moody. She understood that customers were not paying for her life story. They were paying to feel connected to a past they believed they had lost, one with farmhouse kitchens and horse-drawn deliveries. Her own experience of that past, a grandmother's coal stove in a brownstone, was real but harder to market. The Yankee farmer conveyed the same feeling more broadly.
There is a cost. Her real story remained relatively obscure until her own cookbook told it, section by section. For a brand whose value is nostalgia, a broadly shared imagined memory can be worth more than the founder's actual one.
Tactic: Work out which emotional past your customer is actually buying, then ask honestly whether your own biography or a broader shared image communicates it better, and accept the answer even if it is not you.
Principle 11
Keep the first tool on the desk
Rudkin kept the Sears, Roebuck bread mixer from her kitchen days on her desk at the Norwalk plant, among the trade journals and flour samples. "I like to keep it in sight," she said, "so I won't get heady." She could still check the cash balance in her head. She still baked pies and cakes at home on Saturdays. She still wore a 1926 evening wrap.
This is not just sentiment. It is a way of staying connected to the scale where the product is actually made. A founder who remembers the baby scales, the coffee mill, and the Stone Age first loaf is less likely to approve a cost-cutting substitution that ruins the product. Her remark about the slicer, "May the good Lord forgive me," shows the same instinct. She made compromises, but she noticed and acknowledged each one.
Tactic: Keep something from your company's first week where you see it daily, and before any major decision about the product, ask whether the person who used that object would accept the change.
Principle 12
Sell at the top, but keep a seat in the room
In 1961 Rudkin sold Pepperidge Farm to Campbell Soup for about $28 million in Campbell stock, on 1960 sales of $32 million and profits of $1.3 million. She did not simply leave with the money. She joined Campbell's board as its first female director, kept running the business for a time, saw her son William become president in 1962, and later served as chair.
The structure did several things. Taking stock meant her wealth now depended on a larger and more diversified company, a sensible choice for a former broker's associate in her sixties who had already had cancer. The board seat gave her a say in the brand's future. Keeping operational roles gave the transition continuity. With the operating work behind her, she wrote the best-selling cookbook that finally told her real story.
One recent history of mid-century women founders, Boss Lady, places entrepreneurs like her in the context of a postwar economy that seldom made room for them. Rudkin made room through the terms of the deal itself.
Tactic: When you sell, negotiate for governance as well as price: a board seat, an operating role for a set period, and a successor you trust, so the buyer gets your company and your judgment together.
Free playbook
Get The Business Model Playbook
58 business models, one visual page each: how the money flows, the metrics that matter, and who runs it. Free when you join the Faster Than Normal email.
Free. No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Part IIIQuotes and Maxims
In their words
— Margaret Rudkin, on her first attempt at baking, 1937My first loaf of bread should have been sent to the Smithsonian Institution as a sample of Stone Age bread, for it was hard as a rock and about one inch high. So I started over again, and after a few more efforts by trial and error, we achieved what seemed like good bread.
— Margaret RudkinThere isn't a worthwhile thing in the world that can't be accomplished with good hard work. You've got to want something first and then you have to go after it with all your heart and soul.
— Margaret Rudkin, on the Sears, Roebuck mixer kept on her desk, The New Yorker, 1948I like to keep it in sight, so I won't get heady.
— Margaret RudkinThey say life begins at forty. Well, that's how old I was when I baked that first loaf.
— Margaret Rudkin, before sailing to Europe on the Queen Elizabeth, 1948It will be the first time in my life that I have ever done anything just for fun. The boys say they won't allow me to visit a single bakery. Now, isn't that dreadful?
Maxims
- Price the loaf, not the market. Build the best product you can imagine, add up what it costs, and find out whether the market will pay that number.
- The minority is a market. People willing to pay for quality are not a niche to grow out of; in a richer economy, they are where the market is heading.
- Keep the inefficiencies people can taste. Automate whatever the customer cannot notice and keep doing by hand whatever they can.
- Borrow a doctor's letter. A new product needs someone else's credibility before it can build its own.
- Pay the storyteller in shares. The person who places your story where it reaches a national audience is worth part of the company.
- Draw the inside yourself. Control the workflow that makes the product, and give the experts everything else.
- Hire hands, not habits. For skilled work, trainable aptitude is better than confident experience.
- Your returns are raw material. Yesterday's unsold bread can become a product people love.
- Find excellence, then scale it. Most great products already exist somewhere obscure, waiting to be bought and produced at volume.
- Remember the mixer. Keep the first tool where you can see it, so success does not lead you to forget what made the product good.
