Skip to content
Faster Than Normal
Business & Strategy

Loyalists vs Mercenaries

Model #0618Category: Business & StrategyDepth to apply:

By Updated 2 sources

4 min read

Contents

  1. 1. Core Idea
  2. 2. How to See It
  3. 3. How to Use It
  4. 4. Founders & Leaders
  5. 5. Connected Models
  6. 6. One Key Quote
  7. 7. Summary & Further Reading
Business & Strategy
Section 1

Core Idea

Loyalists are people (customers, employees, partners) who stay for mission, relationship, or identity; mercenaries are in it for the best deal or opportunity and will leave when a better one appears. The core idea: both exist in every org and market. Strategy and culture should aim to attract and keep more loyalists where it matters, and accept or design for mercenary behaviour where it’s efficient (e.g. price-sensitive segments, short-term contracts).

Get Faster Than Normal by email

Ideas from founders and companies.

Free newsletter. Unsubscribe anytime.

Or open the full subscribe page.

Section 2

How to See It

Team
You're seeing Loyalists vs Mercenaries when some people stay through tough periods or lower pay because they believe in the mission or team, while others leave for a marginal raise or title — and the org designs retention and hiring for the mix it wants.
Customers
You're seeing Loyalists vs Mercenaries when a segment pays full price and refers others (loyalists) while another segment churns on price or switches to the next promo (mercenaries); positioning and pricing can target one or both.
Section 3

How to Use It

Decide where you need loyalists (core team, key accounts, community) and invest in mission, belonging, and fairness there. Where mercenary behaviour is acceptable (e.g. one-off buyers, contractors), optimise for clear value and low friction instead of loyalty. Don’t over-invest in loyalty for segments that will always shop on price.
Decision filter
"For this group — team, customer, partner — do we need loyalists or is mercenary behaviour fine? If we need loyalists, are we giving them something to be loyal to? If mercenaries are fine, are we efficient and not over-serving?"
As a founder
Identify your “loyalist” roles and segments: who must stay and care? Invest in culture, mission, and equity for them. For the rest, be clear and fair but don’t expect loyalty. Price and package accordingly — loyalists may pay a premium for the relationship; mercenaries need a sharp offer.
Section 5

Founders & Leaders

Herb KelleherCo-founder, Southwest Airlines
Kelleher built Southwest around employees as loyalists: “employees first, customers second, shareholders third.” He bet that loyalist employees would create loyalist customers and that culture would beat pure cost competition. Founders can apply this by deciding which roles and relationships should be loyalist, then investing in the mission, culture, and rewards that give people a reason to stay beyond the next best offer.
Section 7

Connected Models

Reinforces
Intrinsic vs Extrinsic Motivation
Loyalists often have intrinsic motivation (mission, belonging); mercenaries respond to extrinsic (pay, perks). The link: design incentives and culture to strengthen intrinsic motivation where you want loyalists, and accept extrinsic for mercenary segments.
Tension
Skin in the Game
Skin in the game aligns interests; loyalists often have more skin (reputation, relationship). The tension: mercenaries have less skin and will leave. Where you need commitment, create skin (equity, accountability, visibility); where you don’t, keep it transactional.
Leads-to
Trust
Loyalists and trust reinforce each other: trust builds loyalty; loyalty builds trust. Mercenaries are low-trust by definition. Invest in trust where you want loyalists; don’t over-invest where the relationship is meant to be transactional.
Section 8

One Key Quote

"Your employees come first. And if you treat your employees right, guess what? Your customers come back, and that makes your shareholders happy. Start with employees and the rest follows."
— Herb Kelleher
Section 11

Summary & Further Reading

Loyalists stay for mission and relationship; mercenaries optimise for the best deal. Identify where you need loyalists and invest in culture and mission there; where mercenary behaviour is fine, optimise for value and efficiency. Don’t expect loyalty from everyone.
01
Nuts! — Kevin & Jackie Freiberg (1996)
Book
Southwest Airlines culture and “employees first” as a strategy.
02
Drive — Daniel Pink (2009)
Book
Intrinsic motivation and when money isn’t enough; links to loyalist behaviour.
03
The Loyalty Effect — Frederick Reichheld (1996)
Book
Loyalty in customers and employees; economics of retention.

Why this matters next

mental modelsIncentives

Loyalists vs Mercenaries applied the Incentives mental model

mental modelsIntrinsic vs Extrinsic Motivation

Loyalists vs Mercenaries applied the Intrinsic vs Extrinsic Motivation mental model

mental modelsMotivation

Loyalists vs Mercenaries applied the Motivation mental model

mental modelsChurn

Loyalists vs Mercenaries applied the Churn mental model

mental modelsCost

Loyalists vs Mercenaries applied the Cost mental model

mental modelsTransaction

Loyalists vs Mercenaries applied the Transaction mental model

Frequently asked questions

What is Loyalists vs Mercenaries?

Loyalists vs Mercenaries is a mental model used for better thinking and decision-making.

How do you apply Loyalists vs Mercenaries?

To apply Loyalists vs Mercenaries, identify situations where this framework is relevant, then use it as a lens to evaluate your options and decisions. The model is most useful when combined with other complementary mental models.

What category does Loyalists vs Mercenaries fall under?

Loyalists vs Mercenaries falls under the Business & Strategy category of mental models. Other models in this category can be found on the Business & Strategy hub page.

Why is Loyalists vs Mercenaries important?

Loyalists vs Mercenaries is important because it provides a structured way to think about problems that would otherwise be approached with intuition alone. Understanding this model helps you avoid common reasoning errors and make better decisions.

Continue exploring

1L

Mental model

100 People Love

Build something 100 people love rather than something 1 million people kind of l

7H

Mental model

7 Powers (Hamilton Helmer)

The seven — and only seven — sources of durable competitive advantage: Scale Eco

BA

Mental model

BATNA

Best Alternative to a Negotiated Agreement — your power in any negotiation comes

CL

Mental model

Competition is for Losers

Peter Thiel's thesis: every moment spent competing is a moment not spent buildin

DC

Mental model

Disagree and Commit

Once a decision is made after genuine debate, everyone — including dissenters —

DI

Mental model

Disruptive Innovation

Inferior products that start in niche markets and improve until they overtake in

Get Faster Than Normal by email

Ideas from founders and companies.

Free newsletter. Unsubscribe anytime.

Or open the full subscribe page.

Popular Mental Models

First Principles ThinkingOccam's RazorCircle of CompetenceInversionConfirmation BiasSecond-Order ThinkingDunning-Kruger EffectSurvivorship BiasPareto PrincipleOpportunity Cost